Quick Answer • Published November 3, 2025
Thanksgiving dinner may revolve around the turkey, but let’s be honest—everyone’s really waiting for dessert. If you’re looking to skip the stress of baking this year (or simply want to support local businesses with superior pie-making skills), Sacramento and the surrounding area offer exceptional options. Here’s your guide to the best places to order your Thanksgiving pies.
Where Can You Get the Best Pies for Thanksgiving in the Sacramento Area?
Real Pie
True to its name, Real Pie crafts authentic, from-scratch pies that taste like they came straight from grandma’s kitchen. Their commitment to quality ingredients and traditional techniques makes them a reliable choice for classic Thanksgiving flavors like pumpkin, pecan, and apple. The flaky, buttery crusts alone are worth the trip.
Ikeda’s (Auburn & Davis)
A beloved institution with locations in both Auburn and Davis, Ikeda’s has been perfecting their pies for decades. Known for their fruit pies made with California-grown produce, they’re especially famous for their apple and berry options. During Thanksgiving season, their pumpkin pies are equally impressive. Pro tip: if you’re heading to Auburn, make it a day trip and explore the charming downtown while you’re there.
Ettore’s
This Sacramento bakery has built a loyal following for their European-style baking with an American twist. Ettore’s Thanksgiving pies blend Old World technique with classic holiday flavors, resulting in desserts that are both familiar and elevated. Their attention to detail and artisanal approach make these pies feel special.
Sugar Plum (Vegan Pies)
For vegan guests or anyone seeking plant-based options, Sugar Plum proves that dairy-free and egg-free pies can be every bit as delicious as traditional versions. Their vegan pies are crafted with care and creativity, ensuring that everyone at your Thanksgiving table can enjoy a decadent slice of dessert. These pies are so good that even non-vegans won’t feel like they’re missing out.
Fixins Soul Kitchen (Sweet Potato Pie)
When it comes to sweet potato pie—a Thanksgiving staple in many households—Fixins Soul Kitchen is the place to go. Their soulful approach to this Southern classic delivers the perfect balance of sweetness and spice, with a smooth, creamy filling that honors the tradition of authentic soul food. If sweet potato pie is a non-negotiable part of your Thanksgiving table, don’t sleep on Fixins.
I Love Pie Bakeshop
With a name like that, you know they’re serious about their craft. I Love Pie Bakeshop offers a rotating selection of creative and traditional pies, all made with care and quality ingredients. Their seasonal Thanksgiving offerings typically include the classics you’d expect, often with a creative twist that makes them memorable.
Freeport Bakery
A Sacramento institution since 1928, Freeport Bakery has been delighting generations with their baked goods. Their pies are no exception, featuring time-tested recipes and consistent quality that has kept customers coming back for nearly a century. During the holidays, expect traditional favorites executed with the expertise that only comes from decades of experience.
Say Pies!
Rounding out our list is Say Pies!, where playful creativity meets serious baking skills. Their fun approach to pie-making doesn’t compromise on quality, and their Thanksgiving selection typically includes both traditional options and more adventurous flavors for those looking to mix things up at the dessert table.
Planning Tips for Thanksgiving Pie Orders
• Order early: Most bakeries require advance orders for Thanksgiving, often with deadlines a week or more before the holiday. Don’t wait until the last minute!
• Ask about pickup times: Confirm when you can pick up your pies—many bakeries have specific pickup windows on the days before Thanksgiving.
• Consider variety: With so many great options, why not order from multiple bakeries? Your guests will appreciate the selection.
• Don’t forget dietary needs: With options like Sugar Plum’s vegan pies and Fixins’ sweet potato pie, you can ensure all your guests have something delicious to enjoy.
• Order extra: Pies often taste even better as leftovers, and you’ll be glad to have extra when everyone asks for seconds (or thirds).
This Thanksgiving, let Sacramento’s talented bakers handle the pie stress while you focus on enjoying time with family and friends. Whether you’re a traditionalist who needs a perfect pumpkin pie or an adventurous eater looking to try something new, these eight bakeries ensure your Thanksgiving dessert will be nothing short of spectacular.
Real Pie • 2425 24th St Sacramento • (916) 838-4007 • https://realpiecompany.com/
Ikeda’s • 13500 Lincoln Way Auburn • (530) 885-4243 • https://www.ikedas.com/
Ikeda’s • 26295 Mace Blvd Davis • (530) 750-3379 • https://www.ikedas.com/
Ettore’s • 2376 Fair Oaks Blvd Sacramento • (916) 482-0708 • https://ettores.com/
Sugar Plum Vegan • https://www.sugarplumvegan.com/
Fixins Soul Kitchen • 3428 3rd Ave Sacramento • (916) 999-7685 • https://fixinssoulkitchen.com/
I Love Pie Bakeshop • 6241 Fair Oaks Blvd Carmichael • (916) 969-7791 • https://ilovepiebakeshop.com/
Freeport Bakery • 2966 Freeport Blvd Sacramento • (916) 442-4256 • https://freeportbakery.com/
Say Pies! • Fair Oaks • https://saypies.com/
